SPECIES

Northern Cardinal Cardinalis cardinalis

Sylvia L. Halkin, Daniel P. Shustack, M. Susan DeVries, Jodie M. Jawor, and Susan U. Linville
Version: 2.0 — Published February 12, 2021

Appearance

Welcome to Birds of the World!

You are currently viewing one of the free accounts available in our complimentary tour of Birds of the World. In this courtesy review, you can access all the life history articles and the multimedia galleries associated with this account.

For complete access to all accounts, a subscription is required.

Subscribe Now

Already a subscriber? Sign in

Identification

Medium-sized songbird; length of C. c. cardinalis, male 22.2–23.5 cm, female 20.9–21.6 cm (61). Average mass of C. c. cardinalis (sexes combined) 42–48 g, though there appears to be variation with geographic location (within and between subspecies) and time of year. Plumage distinctive—adult male in Definitive Basic is red with black face mask surrounding bill; female in Definitive Basic is grayish tan, with some red on wings, tail, crest, face, and breast, red to red-orange underwings, and pale gray to black face mask. Both sexes have a prominent crest and heavy conical orange-red bill. Juvenile similar to female, but has gray to black bill, shorter crest, less red coloration on the body, and more loosely textured feathers (especially undertail coverts). Males and females gain definitive-like plumage in their first year (Formative Plumage), though many first-year individuals can still be distinguished by retained juvenile primaries, secondaries, and/or rectrices. Males in introduced Hawaiian population can appear duller than mainland birds, but not quantified (R. Pyle, personal communication).

Similar Species

The combination of plumage color, crest, and orange-red conical bill distinguish the Northern Cardinal from all other species within its range, except the Pyrrhuloxia (Cardinalis sinuatus) of the southwestern United States and Mexico. In all plumages, Pyrrhuloxia is distinguished from female and juvenile Northern Cardinal by a shorter bill with a conspicuously decurved upper mandible (yellow to orange in summer adults, horn to brown or grayish brown in winter). Additionally, Pyrrhuloxia plumage is grayer, versus browner in female Northern Cardinal, and male Pyrrhuloxia has a red patch around the base of the bill and variable red coloration down the center of the underparts.

Plumages

Northern Cardinal has 9 functional primaries (numbered distally, p1 to p9), 9 secondaries (numbered proximally, s1 to s9, and including 3 tertials, s7–s9 in passerines), and 12 rectrices (numbered distally, r1 to r6, on each side of the tail). Geographic variation in appearance is moderate. The following plumage descriptions pertain to the northern subspecies C. c. cardinalis; see Systematics: Geographic Variation for variation in 17 other recognized subspecies in the southern United States, Mexico, and Central America.

Sexes are similar in Juvenile Plumage but differ in subsequent plumages; definitive appearance assumed by Second Basic Plumage, although some birds attain definitive-like appearance in Formative Plumage. The following descriptions are based primarily on specimen examination and detailed plumage descriptions from Ridgway (61), Bent (62), Oberholser (63), and Yen (64); see Scott (46), Wiseman (65, 47) and Pyle (66) for age-related criteria.

Natal Down

Present March–August; wide spread in timing here and in other stages linked to a long breeding season with multiple nestings. Hatchlings partially covered with gray down, 6–11 mm long, on coronal, occipital, middorsal, pelvic, scapular, femoral, and greater secondary-covert and median secondary-covert regions at hatching (67).

Juvenile (First Basic) Plumage

Present primarily in April–August. Similar to Definitive Basic female but duller, crest and flight-feathers more brownish, with less red plumage apparent on the body; juvenile body feathers (especially undertail coverts) filamentous due to lower barb density. Juvenile outer primaries and rectrices narrower and more tapered at tips than in later plumages (cf. 46, 47 , 66). Wiseman (47) cautioned that damaged feathers in adults are also replaced by more pointed feathers. Sexes similar.

Auxiliary Formative Plumage

The "Supplemental Plumage" of Thompson and Leu (48); see revisions by Howell et al. (68). Present primarily in June–September. Similar to Juvenile Plumage but variable number of body feathers replaced, the new feathers reported to be brown like juvenile feathers, although in males some body feathers may be red; more study needed on this particular molt stage and resultant plumage.

Formative Plumage

Analogous to "First Basic" or "Basic I" plumage of Humphrey and Parkes (69) and some subsequent authors; see revision by Howell et al. (68). Present in first-year birds, primarily from September to the following August. Similar to Definitive Basic Plumage, however, in most but not all birds, molt limits occur variably among the wing feathers. Retained juvenile feathers appear duller or paler (faded) or tinged brown, and narrower and more tapered (outer primaries and rectrices), contrasting with replaced fresher and better-quality formative feathers, which are brighter red, especially in males. Molt limits can occur among upperwing coverts, with, e.g., inner greater coverts replaced, contrasting with retained juvenile outer greater coverts and primary coverts; or, molt limits can occur among primaries, primary coverts, and secondaries with replacement of just a portion of these feathers in typical molt sequence. Last feathers replaced are the outer primaries and primary coverts, and secondaries among s5–s6. Some birds replace all primaries and primary coverts and retain only 1 juvenile secondary (often s6). Similarly, rectrices can be completely retained, typically in those birds that do not molt any remiges, to completely replaced, typically in birds that have replaced at least 4–6 inner primaries (P. Pyle, personal communication). An unknown proportion of hatch-year birds can replace all body and flight-feathers in the Preformative Molt, becoming indistinguishable from adults in Definitive Basic Plumage (48); it is possible that more birds in southern populations replace all juvenile feathers than do birds in northern populations (70, 66). However, most individuals in Formative Plumage have molt limits or contrasts among feathers of the upperwing and tail, and retained worn, narrow, or brownish-tinged flight feathers contrasting with newly molted uniformly red to reddish flight feathers (66).

Definitive Basic Plumage

Present in birds in their second autumn and beyond, primarily from September to the following August. Newly molted contour feathers of back and neck tipped with gray; by late winter or early spring, feather-tips are worn off and plumage attains maximum coloration (62, JMJ).

Female. Upperparts plain grayish olive or buffy grayish; head with conspicuous crest, variably red to tipped red. Face mask variable: large and dark, much like that of male, to dull grayish, smaller and less distinct than that of male; sometimes nearly white on throat. Upperwing greater coverts and secondaries duller red than primaries and rectrices; duller than those of male. Underparts pale fulvous or buffy, but some individuals can show nearly white coloration on abdomen. Plumage often with small numbers of red or red-tinged feathers above eye, and among auriculars and feathers of the upper breast and flanks. Underwing secondary coverts light orange to light red ; in Ohio (29), female underwing coverts ranged from 8.75 R 4/16 to 10 R 6/13 on Munsell Color Scale. In Mississippi, reflectance measures of underwing plumage from color reflectance spectrometer peak in the 600–700 nm range (JMJ).

Male. Plumage primarily vermilion red, with black face mask that surrounds bill, extends back to eye, and covers chin and throat. Head with conspicuous crest. Red brightest on auricular region, cheeks, and breast. Upperwing greater coverts and secondaries duller red than primaries and rectrices. Contour feathers of back and neck have olive-gray (Munsell 7.8 Y 5.92/2.0) margins that wear away by early spring; tertials and rectrices may also have olive-grayish margins, and flanks include grayish feathers. Rump and uppertail coverts not distinctly lighter in color than back, crest duller red than breast. Underwing secondary coverts as in female. In Ohio, male red breast color ranged from 7.5 R 4/16 to 8.75 R 5/16 on the Munsell Color Scale (29). In Mississippi, highest reflectance measures of red upper-breast plumage from color reflectance spectrometer data peak in the 620–750 nm range (JMJ).

Individuals in Definitive Basic Plumage are separated from most individuals in Formative Plumage by lack of molt limits or contrasts among feathers of the upperwing coverts and among flight feathers of the wing and tail (see Formative Plumage). Rather, the definitive basic upperwing coverts and flight feathers of the wing and tail are uniformly red to reddish, without contrasting worn, narrow, or brownish-tinged feathers (66). After complete Preformative Molt, birds in Formative plumage are usually indistinguishable from Definitive Basic Plumage adults by plumage.

Proximate Control of Coloration

Carotenoid pigments are important components in the plumage of many birds. Red and orange colors in Northern Cardinal result from deposition of carotenoid pigments: canthaxanthin, astaxanthin, phoenicoxanthin, α-doradexanthin, e, e-carotene-3,3´-dione, adonirubin, and 3 unidentified carotenoid pigments (71, 72). A male cardinal showing yellow coloration over the whole body had no red carotenoid pigments identified in its plumage, only yellow carotenoid pigments: lutein, 3’-dehydrolutein, canary-xanthophyll B, and canary-xanthophyll A (72). McGraw et al. (72) suggested the individual might have lacked enzymes necessary for conversion of yellow carotenoids to red forms. McGraw et al. (73) fed captive male cardinals a seed diet that they determined contained only the carotenoids lutein, zeaxanthin, β-cryptoxanthin and β-carotene. Carotenoids in the feathers grown by these males included α-doradexanthin, astaxanthin, canthaxanthin, and adonirubin (73). The authors noted that breast feathers grown by males in captivity were less densely pigmented than those of wild caught males (73, 74). This work shows that cardinals are able to enzymatically alter carotenoids obtained from their diet prior to deposition into feathers; however, the underlying physiological and enzymatic contributions to the range of differences in individual coloration reported among adults of both sexes (e.g., 75, 76, 77, 78) remain to be studied.

The black face mask in both sexes is melanin-based coloration, a pigment type that is independent of diet. In a Mississippi population, male and female testosterone levels were measured through the molt period in captive individuals and it was found that females with higher average testosterone throughout the molt period grew darker face mask feathers (C. P. Winters and JMJ, unpublished data). This association did not hold for males.

Assessment of carotenoid-based plumage for ultraviolet reflectance has not found significant ultraviolet signatures in either sex (76); melanin-based plumage needs to be assessed for ultraviolet signatures.

Aberrant Plumages

Individuals having a mix of male and female plumage infrequently reported from across the species range. See for an example of mixed plumage; the pictured individual, apparently female, was initially thought to be male, but was captured when flushed from a nest where it appeared to be incubating eggs. This bird had an incubation patch, and the nest produced 3 fledglings, fed by both this individual and its social mate, a male with definitive male coloration. Older females of many bird species can obtain male-like plumage as androgen levels decline with age resulting in greater hormonal effects of testosterone (79). Other individuals, potentially bilateral gynandromorphs, have been reported with red on one side and gray-olive on the other (80, 81, 82, 83) ; development and fertility of potential gynandromorphs needs additional assessment in this and other avian species. Also reported are leucistic and partially leucistic individuals (e.g., 84, SUL) , a non-phaeomelanic individual , non-eumelanic individuals , completely yellow individuals (72, 85, also in Alabama and Georgia in 2018, and Florida in 2019) , a dilute individual , and a melanistic male with a black head (86). One rare instance of a banded female that obtained male plumage color in year 5 among 8 years of recapture; she returned to female color in year 6 (87).

Molts

Molt and plumage terminology follows Humphrey and Parkes (69), as modified by Howell et al. (68, 88). Northern Cardinal exhibits a Complex Basic Strategy (cf. 68, 89), including complete prebasic molts, an absent-to-limited auxiliary preformative molt (90, 48), and a partial-to-complete preformative molt but no prealternate molts (91, 92, 46, 93, 94, 63, 66, 95; Figure 1). During molt, patches of old feathers may remain loosely attached.

Geographic variation in average timing and extent of molts likely occurs with latitude of breeding through Mexico and Central America, as a response to variation in environmental constraints, day-length regimes, and breeding seasonality; the Preformative Molt may be more extensive within southern United States populations than in northern populations (66, 95), though confirmation needed.

Prejuvenile (First Prebasic) Molt

Complete, primarily April–July, in and near the nest. From Kinser (67): Tips of primary quills emerge on day 1. Ventral tract evident on day 2 as white lines along sides of abdomen. Ventral cervical and upper abdominal regions, and femoral and humeral tracts, are apparent on day 3. Upperwing greater and median secondary coverts, crural tract, and occipital region visible on day 4. All feathers completely sheathed on day 5, and begin to break open on day 6. By day 7, primaries are 35 mm long and partly sheathed; free from sheaths by day 8. From Wiseman (47): Remiges fully formed in 4 weeks; rectrices erupt about day 7 and mature in 6 weeks; contour feathers develop in irregular patterns within each tract.

Auxiliary Preformative Molt

"Presupplemental Molt" of Thompson and Leu (48); see revisions by Howell et al. (68). Limited or partial, likely sometimes absent altogether, primarily May–September. This molt first described in Northern Cardinal and some sparrows by Sutton (90). On the basis of > 200 museum skins from across the United States (C. Thompson, personal communication): While in the nest or soon after fledging, all or most of body plumage is replaced except for some upperwing secondary coverts; completed within 2 weeks. Molt begins late May to late September and finishes mid-June to early October. Molt likely can be absent in some birds that fledge late, juvenile feathers being directly replaced by formative feathers (P. Pyle, personal communication). Further study is needed on this molt in the Northern Cardinal and in birds in general, as it can be difficult to trace each follicle for activation once or twice during the post-fledging period.

Preformative Molt

"First Prebasic" or "Prebasic I" molt of Humphrey and Parkes (69) and some subsequent authors; see revision by Howell et al. (68). Partial to complete, primarily June–November. Timing and completion of Preformative Molt is variable. Birds hatching in May experience a greater temporal gap between Auxiliary Preformative and Preformative Molt; later-hatching individuals maintain shorter gaps, until those hatching in July have no temporal gap or may skip Auxiliary Preformative molt. Birds hatching after July undergo partial molt; August hatchlings retain all rectrices and some secondaries, September hatchlings replace only a few flight-feathers (46, 93, 94). Sequence of flight-feather replacement as described under Definitive Prebasic Molt. Of 196 juveniles from Ohio and Kentucky, 58% completed molt of all feathers, 23% retained some rectrices, 12% retained all rectrices and some secondaries, and 7% retained all or most flight-feathers (94). In a sample of museum skins (n = 80) from across the United States, 79% replaced all primaries, 56% all rectrices, and 19% all secondaries (C. Thompson, personal communication). By winter, birds with complete molt are usually indistinguishable from adults (48).

Definitive Prebasic Molt

Complete molt of adults, primarily July–October, on or near breeding territories. Northern Cardinals show an unusually low proportion of breeding birds captured molting at MAPS stations (96). Low capture rates of molting cardinals could be due to the reclusive behavior of molting cardinals (SLH, unpublished data, southern Wisconsin population); Pyle et al. (96) suggested the alternate hypothesis that cardinals might disperse from breeding territories for the molting period, but we have found no direct evidence for this in the populations we have studied (SLH, JMJ). In Maryland, the prebasic molt of remiges is completed in most birds during October and a few in early November (94). Induced rectrix growth (feather removed and replacement feather growth rate assessed by growth bars) was influenced by ambient temperature as well as seasonal cues in adults (97). Growth bars visible in rectrices at angle of 77° to proximal rachis (98); growth bar width (an estimate of feather growth rate) on tail feathers not found to covary with plumage color in either sex (99).

Primaries replaced distally (p1 to p9), secondaries replaced proximally from s1, and proximally and distally from the central tertial (s8), and rectrices replaced distally (r1 to r6) on each side of tail, with some variation in sequence possible. Primarily from Wiseman (47): Molt begins in three general regions: (1) all median secondary coverts, (2) small number of feathers in anterior scapular region, and (3) feathers in middle rows of ventral tract on upper breast; head and body feathers molt in irregular patterns and numbers, dorsal feathers first, lateral and ventral feathers later ( ). P1 drops a few days after body molt begins, followed by other primaries at weekly intervals in serial order. Loss of s1, s8, and r1 usually associated with growth of p4; s1 may drop before p4 or it may not drop until p4 is fully grown and p5 is partially grown (C. Thompson, personal communication). S1–s6 replaced in sequential order, proximally; tertials usually molt in order s8-s9-s7 (rarely s7 may drop before s9) and grow rapidly, becoming fully developed before s1–s3 are dropped. Rectrices are replaced in order, distally and rapidly, and are completed before primaries; r5 and r6 are completed last.

Bare Parts

Bill and Gape

Gape of nestlings is red-orange; the yellow edge on the mandibles is useful in discriminating nestling cardinals from Brown-headed Cowbird (Molothrus ater) nestlings in eastern and central populations (see Breeding: Young Birds: Condition at Hatching). Bill of nestlings and juveniles is gray to black, but gradually becomes orange; dark areas of bill coloration may persist to at least January (JMJ). Laskey (100: 31) reported that nestling bill changes to adult color in 65–80 days, though some retain a 1 mm dark upper mandible tip for “several months”. Both males and females have orange-red bills as adults.

The orange-red bill, surrounded by the dark face mask, could provide an aposematic warning or reminder of the cardinal's ability to deliver a painful bite (D. Spector, personal communication).

Iris and Facial Skin

Iris is deep brown, sometimes appearing black.

Tarsi and Toes

Medium brown, sometimes pinkish or orangish.

Measurements

See Systematics and Appendix 1.

Linear Measurements

Males average larger than females in total length, as well as length of wing, tail, and bill, but ranges of values show considerable overlap between the sexes (Appendix 1). Sgueo (101) and Sgueo et al. (102) found no differences in linear measurements (wing chord, tarsus length, tail length, culmen length) in winter and summer individuals in a southwestern Ohio population. No obvious latitudinal trends among subspecies.

Miller et al. (103) assessed a composite measure of bill size from 605 museum specimens collected over 85 years across the species' range in the United States. They found that males have larger bills than females, though bill sizes of both sexes showed extensive variation, with considerable overlap between sexes. For information on environmental correlates of bill size, see Systematics: Geographic Variation.

Mass

Mass varies throughout year; highest values October–April in Ohio, October–February in Tennessee (maximum in January), and February in Indiana (102, 100, 104). Note, avian mass can vary throughout the day as well as the year, and without information on time of day or season when mass was measured, comparisons are problematic, including for some of the presented data. No clear trend of either sex being more massive; in Tennessee, average male mass 45.1 g (n = 85), average female mass 43.0 g (n = 98; 100); however, females were on average more massive than males in southern Indiana, western Ohio, and south-central Wisconsin (Appendix 1). Sgueo et al. (102) found higher body mass in non-breeding season individuals in a southwestern Ohio population (sexes combined) (47.2 g ± 0.9 SD, n = 22) than in breeding season individuals (41.5 g ± 0.3 SD, n = 102); sex ratios for each sampling period not reported. This mass difference was attributed to significantly higher fat scores observed in nonbreeding individuals, as Sgueo et al. (102) found no difference in pectoralis muscle mass between breeding and nonbreeding individuals.

Recommended Citation

Halkin, S. L., D. P. Shustack, M. S. DeVries, J. M. Jawor, and S. U. Linville (2021). Northern Cardinal (Cardinalis cardinalis), version 2.0. In Birds of the World (P. G. Rodewald and B. K. Keeney, Editors). Cornell Lab of Ornithology, Ithaca, NY, USA. https://doi.org/10.2173/bow.norcar.02